Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 

Punctuating With Purpose by ~brytning:iconbrytning:



ma vie est en désordre.

my things don't make sense,
just bits and pieces –
apple bits
(that was always my favourite line of River Tam's)
like so many stars shattered
on a single night:
the night I made my new bed
dry.
dry since
dry now
dry gone.

there are bits inside my head
– apple bits of grey matter stuff –
things that actually happened,
and things that didn't.
things I wish I could forget ,
and things I desperately cling to
for some semblance of meaning.
meaning:
I'm lonely.

heat
and battle:
please let me forget the particulars
and remember just enough
to keep myself from mistakes.
wouldn't that be a blessing?
no more haunting.

all my closest friends
have four feet
and we are all nameless.

it's awful being invisible
it's worse being overlooked

dry then: a lie.
dry since: sometimes
(depending on the condition of my eyes).

my book, my table, my files:
a compilation
a scarily accurate
representa---no rhyming!
it's easier that way
to sever;
cut in two
cut into.

it isn't real.
just keep telling yourself that:
it's.
not.
real.
©2008-2009 ~brytning
:iconbrytning:

Author's Comments

This is my submission for the poetry workshop at :devWriters-Workshop. Touch-up of an older poem with an emphasis on punctuation.

1. Do you usually punctuate your poetry? Why/why not?
I usually do punctuate finished poetry, but in moderation. Most of my lines are only a few words each because I just like jotting thoughts down in a stream-of-consciousness-esque manner.

2. Are there lines in this poem where you were considering other punctuation (or no punctuation)? If so, what were you considering and why?
The original had barely any punctuation, and I'm glad I took the time to add some. I had a bit of trouble with the second stanza. I don't much like using commas in poetry, and I wanted to put a full stop after that parentheses for the longest time, but it looked too weird. I used plenty of semicolons in this one, I guess because when I wrote it I was trying to define some of the things racing through my mind. The three full stops at the end I like very much. I love when prose authors make each word its own sentence, like punching the reader in the eyes.

3. If this a new draft of an old poem, do you feel better about your choices this time, or do you feel as if you were forcing the punctuation use?
Some of the punctuation I'm not quite sure about because it doesn't look quite right but none at all looks entirely wrong, but overall I'm happy with the new changes I made. Yes.


4. Overall, what is the effect you would like this poem to have on the reader? In other words, what are you going for here?
I wrote this for myself because I felt alone and needed an output. It's just disjointed thoughts, really, all affected by change and lack and disorganization which most thoughts are anyway.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconcyberphantom:
"cut in two/ cut into" was my favourite line. I like wordplay like this. I don't understand what the poem means, but from your comments it seems the reader isn't really meant to. I imagined it without any punctuation at all, and found it moved very fast - too fast for my liking, but if you were going for tumbling jumbled thoughts it wouldn't be a bad idea. I appreciated the punctuation for separating the thought stream in interesting ways, highlighting different points that might be overlooked without it there.

--
Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind - Dr. Seuss
:icongrimeden:
I'm not sure the inconsistent punctuation works well. I can appreciate not wanting to burden your language if you feel the grammar is inappropriate, but it feels random.

I'm kinda of torn over having I's and proper nouns capitalized but nothing else. It makes the I's important. The piece must be about self, but with River Tam - the only other capitalized word - I'm searching for significance that ties the actress to the persona. She never comes up again, which makes me wonder why she was capitalized. It can't be out of grammatic concern because you deliberately avoid that approach in the piece.

The last three end-stopped lines of the poem vex me. Fragments with periods is forcing the issue poetically. Typically, short lines in stanzas of long lines have more weight. In the 3rd stanza, where meaning repeats to a realization - the last line is weighted because of the change in form.

You don't need punctuation to moderate movement. You can focus on line length, on stanza length, and on white space (visual/concrete poetry).

I don't mind sparse punctuation, but this seems too inconsistent to me. It turns me off of the piece even though I like the repetition and self-referencing.

I love that you start in French and shift to English with a declarative that the reader - likely a non-French speaker - would be thinking. Also, there is a good amount of rhyme in the piece, despite the persona denying use of a full rhyme in the 8th stanza. Rhyme always helps movement.

There is a lot I like in your disjunction - with only the punctuation jarring me. Punctuation is easy to fix too. I hope you consider revising more.

--
~D
:iconbrytning:
Only capitalizing the I's is just one of my nuances. In shorthand - notes, IMs, texting - I don't capitalize beginnings of words but I do capitalize the I's to make me look a little more important than the average texter I guess. I originally wrote this poem that way on spare index cards and when I transcribed it, adding capitalization just looked wrong. There's nothing significant about it, hah.

Thanks for your comments though! I really appreciate taking the time to help me out! :)

--
"To refuse awards is another way of accepting them with more noise than is normal."
- Peter Ustinov
:iconbrytning:
Thank you for taking the time to leave comments! I really appreciate it :)

--
"To refuse awards is another way of accepting them with more noise than is normal."
- Peter Ustinov
:iconinspiredimperfection:
that's funny, i have the opposite tendency to use little i's even if im punctuating everything else.. i liked the "cut in two, cut into" lines the most :) the four repetitions of dry in the beginning were a bit distracting, although i like the repetition in the following lines :)

--
Brain tingles ftw :bucktooth:

Details

November 12, 2008
1.5 KB

Statistics

5
2 [who?]
96 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Site Map